Bernard Lykes Case Dismissed in General Sessions

A courtroom filled with family, friends, and supporters of Bernard Lykes erupted in applause and relief Wednesday afternoon, October 5, after General Sessions Judge Michael King ruled that he would not bind the charges against Lykes over to the grand jury.

AWAITING PRELIMINARY HEARING - Bernard Lykes (center, blue shirt) sits with family in the court room before proceedings begin. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

Lykes was charged in mid-September with assault and coercion or persuasion of a witness following a lunchroom altercation with a student.

[pms-restrict]

According to Carroll County Sheriff’s Office affidavits at the time, Lykes was accused of striking a student and later confronting them in the office while the teen awaited an administrator.

Deputies wrote that Lykes told the student to “drop it or he would be suspended,” prompting the witness-coercion charge.

Testimony

During Wednesday’s preliminary hearing, the student testified that Lykes had flicked him on the ear, however, he also said it was done as a playful gesture.

OBSERVING EXAMINATION - General Sessions Judge Michael King watches as each attorney makes their case. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

He testified that the two exchanged words, and that he then jokingly pretended to slap Lykes, placing his hand on Lykes’s cheek.

The student then testified that a brief physical interaction followed, which the State argued constituted assault.

District Attorney General Michael Thorne played surveillance footage from the cafeteria that captured the incident.

During cross-examination from defense attorney Anna Cash, the student testified that Lykes was known for cutting up and joking with students, and confirmed he had not seen Lykes act violently with students in the past.

Cash also noted that, after the incident, the student continued through the lunch line, sat through lunch, and did not report the interaction until well after lunch was over.

STATE'S WITNESS - West Carroll Jr./Sr. High School Assistant Principal Leslie Booker on the witness stand. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

Regarding the coercion charge, the student acknowledged that Lykes told him, “You better drop it or I’ll get you suspended.” He later confirmed that Lykes also said shortly after, “If you’re going to tell what happened, tell the whole thing.”

Under further questioning, the student acknowledged that he understood the second statement to mean Lykes meant for him to be truthful and complete in his account.

Assistant Principal Leslie Booker testified that the student reported the incident to her after lunch.

EXAMINATION - District Attorney General Michael Thorne examines state's witness Leslie Booker. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

She said that once she reviewed the cafeteria video, she determined the situation required administrative review beyond her authority and contacted her supervisor.

Booker then testified that, after she reviewed the footage with her supervisor, she went back into her office, and Lykes was in there with the student.

She testified that she did not hear their conversation. She asked the student to step out.

Closing Arguments and Judgement

STATE'S CLOSING ARGUMENTS - District Attorney General Michael Thorn argues that the testimony and video footage speak for themselves, and that Judge King should bind the case over. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

In her closing arguments, Cash emphasized that the interaction escalated only after the student initiated the gesture of placing his hand on Lykes’s face, and that Lykes had been backed against a lunchroom table with limited space to move.

The defense further argued that no official proceeding was underway at the time of the office conversation, and therefore the legal standard for coercion was not met.

After reviewing the testimony and video, Judge King ruled that the evidence did not meet the threshold to advance either charge.

DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENTS - Attorney Anna Cash argues that the state did not provide sufficient evidence to warrant binding the case over to a grand jury. Jesse Joseph/ Carroll County Observer

“What I observed does not rise to the level of assault,” King said.

He added that the evidence was also insufficient to establish coercion, citing the admission of Lykes’s emphasis on the student to tell the whole story.

King dismissed the charges at the General Sessions level.

The District Attorney’s Office may still choose to present the case directly to a grand jury.

JUDGE GIVES HIS RULING - General Sessions Judge Michael King says the state did not provide him with enough evidence to justify sending the case over to the grand jury. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

After proceedings, defense attorney Cash said, “We are pleased with the outcome of the case, and now everybody can move forward and heal.”

Lykes embraced his supporters with hugs and thanks as they gathered around him. Many expressed relief that the month-long uncertainty had finally come to an end.

Carroll County Observer will keep track of the case, should the District Attorney’s Office choose to present it to the grand jury.

RELIEF - Bernard Lykes smiles after the Judge King dismisses the case. Jesse Joseph/Carroll County Observer

[/pms-restrict]

Bernard Lykes Case Dismissed in General Sessions

Huntingdon’s Friday-Night Opponent Loses Head Coach Amid FBI Drug Trafficking Bust

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Welcome Back!

Retrieve your password

Bernard Lykes Case Dismissed in General Sessions

Log in or Subscribe to continue reading.

Huntingdon’s Friday-Night Opponent Loses Head Coach Amid FBI Drug Trafficking Bust

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Welcome Back!

Retrieve your password